Discover the Serenity of Horseshoe Cienega Lake in the Arizona White Mountains

Nestled within the breathtaking Arizona White Mountains, Horseshoe Cienega Lake is a gem that promises a tranquil and rewarding experience for outdoor enthusiasts. Whether you’re looking to fish, camp, or simply enjoy the beauty of nature, this lake has something to offer everyone. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore everything you need to know about Horseshoe Cienega Lake, from its size and location to the required permits and available amenities. Get ready to plan your perfect adventure to one of Arizona’s hidden treasures.

Horseshoe Cienega Lake Location and Overview

Horseshoe Cienega Lake is located in the picturesque Arizona White Mountains, approximately 20 miles southeast of Pinetop-Lakeside, right off Highway 273. Situated at an elevation of around 8,000 feet, this serene lake is surrounded by lush forests and stunning mountain landscapes, making it a perfect destination for those seeking a peaceful retreat in nature.

The lake spans roughly 120 acres, offering plenty of space for various recreational activities. The name “Horseshoe Cienega Lake” reflects the unique shape of the lake and the marshy wetlands, or “cienegas,” that border its shores. The surrounding area is rich in wildlife, with opportunities to spot deer, elk, and a variety of bird species.

Feeding Stream and Natural Features

Horseshoe Cienega Lake is fed by Horseshoe Creek a branch off of the North Fork of the White River, a pristine waterway that meanders through the high country of the White Mountains. The river’s clear, cold waters make the lake an ideal habitat for trout, and it’s a popular spot for anglers hoping to catch a big one.

The lake’s elevation and location within the White Mountains provide a cool and refreshing climate, even during the hot summer months. This makes it a perfect escape from the Arizona heat, offering visitors a chance to enjoy outdoor activities in a comfortable setting.

Camping at Horseshoe Cienega Lake

For those who wish to immerse themselves fully in the natural beauty of the area, camping at Horseshoe Cienega Lake is highly recommended. The lakes campgrounds provide aproximately 70 spaces that cater to both tent campers and RV enthusiasts. It features well-maintained sites equipped with picnic tables, fire rings, and grills. Some sites offer stunning views of the lake, allowing you to wake up to the sight of the sun rising over the water.

Campground Amenities:

• Drinking water
• Vault toilets
• Picnic areas
• Firewood for sale (when available)
• Access to hiking trails
• Small general store
• Open Memorial Day through Labor Day (opening depending upon weather)
• Open Wednesday – Sunday 8:00 to 5:00

Camping fees are reasonable, but it’s essential to note that this area is managed by the White Mountain Apache Tribe. Therefore, a tribal camping permit is required for all visitors who plan to go fishing, hiking, or stay overnight. Permits can be conveniently purchased at the on-site store, which also offers basic supplies and snacks.

Fishing at Horseshoe Cienega Lake

Fishing is one of the primary draws to Horseshoe Cienega Lake. The lake is regularly stocked with rainbow trout, and anglers can also find brown trout and brook trout in its waters. The cooler temperatures and rich aquatic life create the perfect conditions for fishing throughout most of the year.

Fishing Tips:

• Early morning and late evening are the best times to fish.
• Fly fishing is particularly effective here, with many anglers having success using nymphs and dry flies.
• Shore fishing can be productive, but having a small boat or kayak will allow you to reach some of the deeper areas where larger fish tend to gather.
• Anglers often have luck with PowerBait, worms, and spinners.

A White Mountain Apache Tribe fishing permit is required to fish in Horseshoe Cienega Lake. These permits can also be purchased at the lake’s store, ensuring that you’re ready to cast your line as soon as you arrive.

Boating and Boat Rentals

While Horseshoe Cienega Lake is not large enough for high-speed boating, it is perfect for small boats, canoes, and kayaks. The calm waters provide an ideal environment for paddling and exploring the lake at a leisurely pace.

Also, there are boat rental services which can be purchased at the small general store directly at the lake.  Or if preferred, visitors can to bring their own watercraft. Use of electric trolling motors only.

The gentle currents and scenic surroundings make for a peaceful and enjoyable boating experience.

Please note that only electric trolling motors are allowed.

White Mountain Apache Tribe Permits

As mentioned, the area surrounding Horseshoe Cienega Lake is managed by the White Mountain Apache Tribe. To ensure that you comply with tribal regulations and support the maintenance of this beautiful area, it’s crucial to obtain the necessary permits.

Required Permits:

• Camping Permit: Required for all overnight stays at the lake’s campgrounds.
• Fishing Permit: Required for all anglers, regardless of age.
• Day-Use Permit: Required for any day-use activities, such as picnicking or hiking.

These permits can be easily purchased at the on-site store, which is conveniently located near the lake. The store staff can provide information on the latest fishing conditions, camping availability, and any other details you might need for a successful visit.  Permits are also available at the Hon-Dah Casino gas station.

Directions to Horseshoe Cienega Lake

Getting to Horseshoe Cienega Lake is relatively straightforward, whether you’re coming from the Phoenix area or elsewhere in Arizona. Here are the directions to help you reach this serene destination:

From Phoenix:

1. Take US-60 East towards Globe.
2. Continue on US-60 through Globe, then turn left onto AZ-77 North towards Show Low.
3. In Show Low, turn right onto AZ-260 East towards Pinetop-Lakeside.
4. Continue on AZ-260 East until you reach the turnoff for AZ-273 South towards Sunrise Park Resort.
5. Follow AZ-273 South for approximately 10 miles.
6. Turn left onto Forest Road 249, and continue for about 3 miles to reach the lake.

From Flagstaff:

1. Take I-40 East towards Winslow.
2. Exit onto AZ-77 South towards Show Low.
3. Follow AZ-77 South through Snowflake, then turn left onto AZ-260 East towards Pinetop-Lakeside.
4. Follow the same directions from Show Low as above.

The roads leading to Horseshoe Cienega Lake are well-maintained, though some sections may be gravel or dirt. It’s advisable to check road conditions before your trip, especially during the winter months when snow can make travel more challenging.

Nearby Attractions and Landmarks

Horseshoe Cienega Lake is part of a network of lakes and recreational areas in the White Mountains, offering plenty of options for exploration. Some nearby attractions include:

• Sunrise Park Resort: Located just a short drive away, Sunrise Park Resort is a popular destination for skiing, snowboarding, and summer mountain biking.
• Big Lake: Another excellent fishing and camping destination, Big Lake is known for its larger size and variety of trout species.
• Greer: This charming mountain village offers a peaceful retreat with cozy cabins, hiking trails, and opportunities to spot wildlife.

Final Thoughts

Horseshoe Cienega Lake is a true hidden gem in the Arizona White Mountains, offering a perfect blend of natural beauty, outdoor adventure, and tranquility. Whether you’re an avid angler, a camping enthusiast, or simply looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life, this lake has something to offer.

With its cool, crisp air and stunning scenery, Horseshoe Cienega Lake provides an ideal backdrop for creating lasting memories. Don’t forget to secure the necessary permits, pack your fishing gear, and prepare for an unforgettable experience in one of Arizona’s most serene mountain destinations.

Find More Arizona White Mountain Lakes Here:

See Wikipedia Info Here: